Summary
Under Ontario's Human Rights Code, employers must accommodate employees' needs related to protected grounds such as disability, family status, and creed. They must do so up to the point of undue hardship, which is a high bar. Accommodation is a shared process. You need to make your needs known and cooperate, and your employer needs to look seriously at options. If your employer refuses, ignores you, or ends your employment instead, you may have a human rights claim.
Asking for accommodation can feel risky. Many people worry about being seen as difficult or losing their job. Knowing how the process works makes it easier to ask.
What is the duty to accommodate?
The duty to accommodate is an employer's legal obligation to adjust rules, duties, or the workplace so that an employee is not disadvantaged because of a protected ground.
It comes from the Human Rights Code, RSO 1990, c H.19. Section 5 protects employees from discrimination. Sections 11 and 17 require employers to accommodate unless doing so would cause undue hardship.
Common accommodations include:
modified duties or a gradual return to work after illness or injury
flexible hours or a changed shift to meet childcare or eldercare needs
time off for medical appointments or religious observance
assistive technology, ergonomic equipment, or a quieter workspace
working from home, where the job allows it
moving to a different position the employee can do
Who is entitled to accommodation at work?
Any employee whose need is connected to a protected ground under the Code may be entitled to accommodation. The most common grounds in the workplace are disability (including mental health conditions and addictions), family status, creed, sex (including pregnancy and breastfeeding), and age.
Disability is broad. It covers physical, mental health, learning, and episodic conditions, and temporary conditions in many cases.
Family status covers the parent and child relationship, including caring for a child or an aging parent. In Ontario, the HRTO has applied a contextual approach to family status claims. See Misetich v Value Village Stores Inc, 2016 HRTO 1229.
What does "undue hardship" mean?
Undue hardship is a high standard. Some inconvenience or cost is expected. Under section 17(2) of the Code, only three factors are considered: cost, outside sources of funding, and health and safety requirements.
Business inconvenience, employee morale, and customer preference are not on that list. An employer that claims undue hardship must prove it with real evidence, not assumptions. See British Columbia (Public Service Employee Relations Commission) v BCGSEU, [1999] 3 SCR 3 (often called Meiorin).
Accommodation must be reasonable. It does not have to be perfect, and it does not have to be the exact option you prefer.
What do I need to tell my employer?
You need to tell your employer that you have a need connected to a protected ground, and what you need. You do not have to use any special words. Asking in writing is best, so there is a record.
For disability-related requests, your employer can usually ask for medical information about your functional limitations and restrictions. In most cases, it is not entitled to your diagnosis. The Ontario Human Rights Commission's Policy on ableism and discrimination based on disability explains this in more detail.
A helpful medical note usually covers:
what you can and cannot do
the accommodation recommended
how long the restrictions are expected to last
What does my employer have to do?
Your employer has two duties. It must take your request seriously and investigate options (the procedural part). It must also actually provide accommodation unless it would cause undue hardship (the substantive part). Ontario decisions recognize both duties. See ADGA Group Consultants Inc v Lane, 2008 CanLII 39605 (ON SCDC).
In practice, your employer should:
respond to your request promptly
ask for only the information it needs
consider a range of options, including changes to your current job and other positions
keep your medical information confidential
explain its decision, especially if it says no
You also have responsibilities. You need to cooperate, provide reasonable information, and consider reasonable proposals, even if they are not ideal. The Supreme Court of Canada described accommodation as a shared responsibility in Central Okanagan School District No 23 v Renaud, [1992] 2 SCR 970.
What can I do if my employer refuses to accommodate me?
Start inside the workplace, and keep a record at every step.
Put your request in writing if you have not already done so. Refer to the Human Rights Code and attach supporting information.
Ask for the refusal in writing, with reasons.
Propose alternatives. Show you are open to options.
Use internal routes. That includes HR, a workplace accommodation policy, or your union if you have one.
Get legal advice if the refusal stands or the process stalls.
If your employer refuses without good reason, delays for months, or disciplines or fires you instead of accommodating you, you may have a claim. In most cases you can file an application with the Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario within one year. If you were fired, you may also have a wrongful dismissal claim. See our posts on filing an HRTO application and on being fired without cause.
Unionized employees usually raise accommodation issues through a grievance. Federally regulated employees use the Canadian Human Rights Act process.
Frequently asked questions
Can my employer fire me for asking for accommodation? No. Firing or punishing someone for requesting accommodation can be discrimination and reprisal under the Code.
Do I have to tell my employer my diagnosis? Usually not. Your employer generally needs your restrictions and limitations, not your diagnosis. There are limited exceptions.
Can my employer deny accommodation because it would be inconvenient? No. Inconvenience alone is not undue hardship. The employer must show hardship based on cost, outside funding, or health and safety.
Does accommodation apply to mental health? Yes. Mental health conditions are disabilities under the Code and are treated the same way as physical conditions.
What if my employer offers an accommodation I don't like? If the offer is reasonable and meets your needs, you may be expected to accept it. If it does not meet your restrictions, explain why in writing and suggest alternatives.
This post provides general information about Ontario human rights and employment law. It is not legal advice. Contact Bird Bolt Law to discuss your circumstances.